While walking along
a Detroit sidewalk
last month, a
friend's 6-year-old
son picked up a
small, unremarkable
golden locket. He
chipped away dirt
clumps before
reading, "Made in
China."
He offered me the
locket. I told him I
didn't see the
words. "Where do you
see that?" I asked.
He grinned, then
exploded with
laughter—he was
fooling me.
Like the best jokes,
it contained a
nugget of truth. My
friend's son had
been reading for
only a year or two,
but he'd come across
"made in China"
enough to know that
the phrase is on
countless items. The
phrase has become a
part of American
life.
Wary of 'Made in
China'
Lately, a steady
pulse of negative
news about poisoned
pet food and
toothpaste and
abysmal working
conditions in China
has made more of us
wary of the phrase.
Just last week, the
Boy Scouts recalled
more than a million
badges tainted with
lead paint and the
Consumer Product
Safety Commission
recalled another
550,000 products.
Since August, more
than 21 million
Chinese-made
products --
including toys from
Dora the Explorer,
Thomas & Friends and
Baby Einstein lines
-- have been
recalled. Three
children have been
killed in defective
playpens, and pets
have been poisoned
from tainted food.
Factor in rampant
environmental
problems and,
increasingly, we're
seeking products
made anywhere but
China.
Misplaced trade
priorities are at
the heart of these
problems. As
corporations have
outsourced American
manufacturing jobs,
our government has
sold short the
system that protects
against unsafe
products, allowing
workers to be
exploited in
ruthless pursuit of
low-cost
goods. We must
drastically improve
this dangerous
arrangement.
In August, China
Labor Watch, a
U.S.-based workers'
rights group, issued
a report detailing
labor violations and
brutal conditions.
China's Working
Conditions
"Wages are low,
benefits are
nonexistent, work
environments are
dangerous and living
conditions are
humiliating," the
report said of its
investigation into
plants that make
toys for
multinational
companies.
Two-thirds of
China's power comes
from coal, and it
comes at a steep
price. The Chinese
government reported
more than 4,700
deaths related to
coal mining13 a
day, on average—last year, while
independent groups
estimate 20,000
deaths.
Working conditions
in China need to be
improved. Norms for
working standards
worldwide are being
set in China.
Change is happening
in China, although
not easily. In
response to mass
protests by workers,
the Chinese
government drafted a
law strengthening
the workers' union.
The law would
require employers to
enter into contracts
with employees,
allow workers to
change jobs and
oblige companies to
bargain over health
and safety issues.
However, U.S.
corporations
objected, saying
they would make it
harder to do
business.
My visit to China
convinced me that
China is not
building a middle
class capable of
sustaining economic
growth. In fact, it
created a situation
that allows
corporations to
exploit poorly paid
workers in often
unsafe conditions.
It's time that
companies respect
workers' rights here
and in China.
Here at home, the
Bush administration
has relaxed the
regulatory system
that protects
workers. By allowing
goods to be produced
in a shallowly
regulated China
rather than in the
much safer United
States, we're seeing
our safety standards
are lowered.
Simultaneously, the
Bush administration
has cut our capacity
to inspect imports.
The New York Times
reports that the
Consumer Product
Safety Commission
"has one lone toy
tester, at an
outdated lab in
Maryland, for the
whole country." And
while we are
importing four times
more food from China
than we did in 1996,
our Food and Drug
Administration
inspects less than 1
percent of imports.
What sort of
oversight is that?
Trade should be
fair, to benefit our
citizens and our
trading partners. We
must lift labor
standards in the
United States and
around the world.