Laidlaw, FirstGroup Teamsters Question Laidlaw Board
about Effects of British Buyout on Job Security, Labor Relations at Annual
Shareholder Meeting in Illinois
February 9, 2007
(Washington, DC) – Following today’s announcement of a $3.6 billion
FirstGroup PLC takeover of Laidlaw International Inc. (NYSE: LI) at the Laidlaw
annual shareholders meeting, Teamsters General President Jim Hoffa called for
both companies to ensure that workers’ job security would be protected and that
the merged company’s service and labor relations would not be tainted by
FirstGroup’s troubled record in the U.S. Together, FirstGroup and Laidlaw would
dominate the privatized school bus market in the United States.
“This buyout means that FirstGroup becomes a more highly unionized company,
with an additional 7,000 Laidlaw Teamsters who have served their company and
their communities for decades,” Hoffa said. “We are determined to drive up
standards in the school bus and passenger transport industries and we stand
prepared to protect our members’ interests as this buyout progresses.”
New Orleans Laidlaw driver Zandra Batise questioned Laidlaw Chief Executive
Kevin Benson about his updated employment agreement that would provide him with
a golden parachute in the event of a merger. Batise questioned why Benson would
be entitled to two years of salary, club fees, medical payments, retirement and
other perquisites, when workers in New Orleans have not received the pay they
were promised in writing. Benson replied, “We’re both paid exactly the same –
the market.”
First Student drivers from Danville, Illinois, questioned Benson about the
combined company’s intentions regarding labor relations, suggesting that the
takeover could provide an opportunity to work with its union membership to
improve conditions and reduce driver turnover, a critical problem in the school
bus industry. First Student’s turnover rate in the U.S. is 35 percent.
FirstGroup, at its July 2006 Annual General Meeting in Aberdeen, Scotland,
committed to enforce a policy of neutrality toward unions in the U.S.
“We are absolutely committed to stamping out anti-union behavior and you have
our undertaking that we will do what is necessary to remain neutral as far as
union membership is concerned,” said Martin Gilbert, FirstGroup Chairman at the
meeting.
“We absolutely intend to hold this company to that commitment. In light of
today’s announcement and the effects of such a merger on children, communities
and workers, it is time for FirstGroup to join us in a sincere dialogue about
worker rights, safety, and service,” Hoffa said. “We strongly believe that
labor peace promotes the financial success of any company.”
Hoffa had earlier expressed concern that FirstGroup’s checkered service
record in the U.S. could negatively affect the long-term profitability of a
combined company. First Student, FirstGroup’s U.S. subsidiary, has caused
several school districts to rebid their transportation contracts after the
company failed to provide adequate, timely and safe transportation to students.
Some districts, like Jacksonville, Florida, have already reassigned large
portions of First Student work to other providers.
Recently, extremely serious safety violations came to light in Ohio where
First Student is headquartered. On January 25, Columbus’ school system closed
down because First Student had not completed background checks on their drivers,
one of whom had a record of three driving under the influence violations. The
following day in St. Paul, Minnesota, a First Student driver, who had killed a
man while driving a school bus the previous week, was found to have been driving
with a suspended license at the time of the accident. The subsequent
investigation found that he already had a pattern of recent traffic violations.
Further, Teamsters fear that the buyout of Laidlaw could create disruptions
and loss of business for the combined company since many school districts across
the United States are required to award work to multiple providers to ensure
quality service and stimulate competition. Already, one district in Chattanooga,
Tennessee had chosen to end its relationship with First Student and award work
to Laidlaw. The district may now find itself back in business with a provider it
had found unsatisfactory.
During the meeting, Laidlaw’s counsel Beth Corvino declined to respond to a
question regarding potential loss of business as a result of merged company,
saying only that such issues would not be addressed on the company’s proxy.
Today’s announcement places the top school bus providers in the U.S. under
British ownership. London-based National Express, which operates Durham School
Services in the U.S., would become the number two provider of school bus
transportation in the U.S.
The International Brotherhood of Teamsters represent 1.4 million hardworking
men and women throughout the United States and Canada, including more than
11,000 workers employed by Laidlaw and FirstGroup.