Union Urges Protection of Public Interest in Tribune
Deal
October 31, 2007
(Washington, D.C.) -- The International Brotherhood of Teamsters testified at
today’s Federal Communications Commission (FCC) hearing regarding diversity and
localism in media ownership, raising concerns about the separation of ownership
and management under applications filed by the Tribune Company [NYSE: TRB]. The
union also held a rally outside the hearing in support of public interest
protections.
Applications by the Tribune Company for transfer of ownership and waivers of
the FCC’s newspaper/broadcast cross-ownership rules are pending before the FCC.
The proposed transaction would transfer 100 percent of the company’s ownership
to an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP), but give employees no voice in the
governance of the plan or the operating company. Rather, total control of the
company would reside with its new chairman, Sam Zell.
George Tedeschi, Teamsters International Vice President and President of the
Graphic Communications Conference of the Teamsters, testified at the hearing on
behalf of 2,000 Teamster-represented Tribune employees.
"Section 310(d) of the FCC’s rules forbids a broadcast licensee from giving
third parties ultimate control over station personnel, programming, and
finances," Tedeschi said. "In other words, the owners of a station must be the
ones who have ultimate management responsibility for the station. The Tribune-Zell
transaction calls this rule into question."
- Zell clearly would control the Tribune, but he would not be an owner.
Although a trust established for the benefit of his family would hold notes
and warrants and would have the right to designate two of nine members of
the Tribune’s board, neither Zell nor his family trust would be owners of
Tribune stock.
- The ostensible owners of the Tribune would be the Tribune’s employees,
as beneficiaries of the Tribune ESOP Plan that would hold 100 percent of the
Tribune’s stock. But as proposed, the employees would have no role in the
selection of the Tribune’s directors, who establish company policy and
appoint the officers who run the company; and would have no opportunity or
ability to select the Tribune ESOP Plan trustee
“This separation of ownership and management is unprecedented and would set a
new, and very low, standard for compliance with the Communications Act’s public
interest requirements, which are the basis for the localism and diversity
principles in broadcasting,” Tedeschi said.
Teamsters General President Jim Hoffa called on the FCC to ensure protections
for the public interest in any action on the Tribune Company waiver requests.
“By rubberstamping the Tribune application, the FCC could violate its own rules
and policies which forbid a broadcast company from giving ultimate control to an
unaccountable third party,” Hoffa said.
Founded in 1903, the International Brotherhood of Teamsters represents 1.4
million hardworking men and women in the United States, Canada and Puerto Rico.